There are good reasons to do it. Insurance can help bring new patients through the door, make therapy more affordable, and provide a relatively steady stream of referrals. But it also comes with tradeoffs. Reimbursement rates may be lower than your private-pay fee, billing takes time, and insurance companies have their own rules and documentation requirements.
So, is accepting insurance the right move for your practice?
There isn’t a single answer that works for every therapist. Your decision should take into account the kind of practice you want to build, the patients you hope to serve, your specialty, your local market, and what you’re willing to take on from an administrative standpoint.
If you’re opening a practice or trying to fill an existing schedule, insurance can be a useful way to attract new patients.
Many people start their search by looking for providers who accept their insurance. Being in-network with several commonly used plans can put your practice in front of people who may never have found you otherwise.
This can be particularly helpful early on, when building a steady caseload is often the biggest challenge.
For many patients, the cost of therapy is a major consideration.
Someone who can’t comfortably afford a $175 or $200 private-pay session may be able to manage a much smaller copay or coinsurance amount. Insurance participation can therefore make ongoing treatment possible for people who might otherwise have to go without care.
For therapists who place a high value on accessibility, this can be an important reason to participate with insurance.
A practice doesn’t necessarily have to rely entirely on referrals, networking, or marketing to generate new patients.
Insurance directories and payer referrals can provide another source of potential clients. In areas where there is strong demand for behavioral health services, this can help a therapist maintain a fairly consistent schedule.
That predictability can be especially valuable when you’re trying to grow a practice and establish reliable revenue.
Of course, insurance isn’t without its drawbacks.
This is usually the first concern therapists have, and for good reason.
An insurance company may reimburse considerably less than what you would charge a private-pay patient for the same service. The difference can become significant over the course of a year.
That’s why it’s important to look at actual reimbursement rates before joining a network. A full schedule isn’t necessarily a profitable schedule if the reimbursement doesn’t support the time and overhead involved in providing care.
Rates can also vary depending on the payer, plan, CPT code, specialty, and geographic market.
Insurance billing isn’t simply a matter of sending in a claim and waiting for a check.
There may be eligibility checks, authorizations, claim corrections, denials, payment posting, credentialing, insurance correspondence, and follow-up on unpaid claims. Someone also has to keep track of patient balances and explain insurance-related issues when questions arise.
Some therapists handle these tasks themselves. Others hire a biller or outsource the work.
Either way, the administrative side of insurance needs to be factored into the economics of your practice.
Insurance participation can also affect how you manage the clinical side of your practice.
Depending on the payer and the patient’s plan, you may have requirements involving documentation, treatment plans, medical necessity, authorizations, coding, and other aspects of care.
None of this necessarily makes insurance a bad choice. But you should understand what you’re agreeing to before signing a contract.
It’s easy to think of the decision as either accepting insurance or becoming a completely private-pay practice.
In reality, there is another option: a hybrid model.
A therapist might participate with two or three insurance plans while remaining out-of-network with others. The plans you choose could be the ones that offer reasonable reimbursement, have a patient population that fits your practice, and aren’t excessively difficult to work with.
This approach can give you some of the benefits of insurance while allowing you to maintain more control over your schedule, fees, and overall practice model.
For some therapists, this middle ground makes the most sense.
Rather than asking whether insurance is “good” or “bad,” start by looking at what you actually want from your practice.
How quickly do you need to build your caseload?
If you’re starting from scratch and need patients quickly, accepting insurance may give you an advantage.
Who do you want to serve?
If your goal is to make treatment available to a broad range of patients, insurance participation may be an important part of that strategy.
What does your local market look like?
The answer can be very different depending on where you practice. In some markets, patients have dozens of therapists to choose from. In others, there may be enough demand for a particular specialty that a therapist can maintain a full caseload without accepting insurance.
What are the actual reimbursement rates?
Don’t assume that all insurance companies pay roughly the same amount. They don’t.
Look at the rates for the services you expect to provide and compare them with your expenses, desired income, and the amount of time involved in treating and billing each patient.
How much administrative work are you willing to take on?
If you’d prefer to spend your time almost entirely on clinical work, insurance may be less appealing unless you have someone else managing the billing and administrative responsibilities.
Would you rather see more patients at a lower reimbursement rate or fewer patients at a higher private-pay rate?
There isn’t a universally correct answer. It depends on the kind of practice you want and what makes sense financially for you.
It’s tempting to compare insurance plans based solely on the fee schedule.
That can be a mistake.
A plan with slightly lower reimbursement might still be worthwhile if it has a large patient base, sends consistent referrals, and pays claims reliably. On the other hand, a plan with a higher reimbursement rate may become much less attractive if claims are frequently denied or the administrative requirements consume a significant amount of your time.
Think about the whole relationship.
Consider reimbursement, potential patient volume, payment reliability, administrative requirements, and whether the people covered by the plan are actually the patients you want to serve.
The numbers matter, but so does everything that happens around those numbers.
For some therapists, the answer will be yes. Insurance can be an effective way to build a busy practice while making therapy more accessible to patients.
For others, a private-pay model may be a better fit. It can offer more control over fees and scheduling, reduce insurance-related administrative work, and potentially produce more revenue per appointment.
And there are plenty of therapists for whom a combination of the two makes the most sense.
The important thing is not to accept insurance simply because it seems like the thing you’re supposed to do.
Take a close look at the numbers and the practical realities before signing a participation agreement. Understand the reimbursement rates, contract requirements, administrative workload, and patient population associated with each plan.
Most importantly, think about the practice you actually want to build.
The right insurance strategy isn’t necessarily the one that fills your schedule the fastest. It’s the one that supports your financial goals, your preferred way of practicing, and the patients you want to serve.
Psychiatric Billing Associates works with behavioral health practices that participate with insurance and helps manage the administrative side of the revenue cycle. Services can include eligibility verification, claims processing, payment posting, and insurance follow-up.
If you’re considering joining an insurance network, understanding the financial and administrative implications beforehand can help you make a more informed decision—and avoid committing to an arrangement that doesn’t make sense for your practice.
Testimonials from Mental Health Professionals
I could not have found a better group to work with than Psychiatric Billing Associates. The hassles' and headaches of managing a practice...
Thank you for substantially helping with this difficult aspect of my practice. I appreciate all your help and the patients are grateful for your courtesy...
